{"poem_id":"0b8b1899dd68","title":"丹青引赠曹将军霸","poet_name":"杜甫","poet_id":"du-fu","author_id":"515ea88d1858","dynasty":"唐代","form":"","pinyin":"dān qīng yǐn zèng cáo jiāng jūn bà dù fǔ táng dài jiāng jūn wèi wǔ zhī zǐ sūn yú jīn wéi shù wéi qīng mén yīng xióng gē jù suī yǐ yǐ wén cǎi fēng liú jīn shàng cún xué shū chū xué wèi fū rén dàn hèn wú guò wáng yòu jūn dān qīng bù zhī lǎo jiāng zhì fù guì yú wǒ rú fú yún kāi yuán zhī zhōng cháng yǐn jiàn chéng ēn shuò shàng nán xūn diàn líng yān gōng chén shǎo yán sè jiāng jūn xià bǐ kāi shēng miàn liáng xiàng tóu shàng jìn xián guān měng jiàng yāo jiān dà yǔ jiàn bāo gōng è gōng máo fà dòng yīng zī sà shuǎng lái hān zhàn xiān dì tiān mǎ yù huā cōng huà gōng rú shān mào bù tóng shì rì qiān lái chì chí xià jiǒng lì chāng hé shēng cháng fēng zhào wèi jiāng jūn fú juàn sù yì jiàng cǎn dàn jīng yíng zhōng sī xū jiǔ chóng zhēn lóng chū yì xǐ wàn gǔ fán mǎ kōng yù huā què zài yù tà shàng tà shàng tíng qián yì xiāng xiàng zhì zūn hán xiào cuī cì jīn yǔ rén tài pú jiē chóu chàng dì zǐ hán gàn zǎo rù shì yì néng huà mǎ qióng shū xiàng gàn wéi huà ròu bú huà gǔ rěn shǐ huá liú qì diāo sàng jiāng jūn huà shàn gài yǒu shén bì féng jiā shì yì xiě zhēn jí jīn piāo bó gān gē jì lǚ mào xún cháng xíng lù rén tú qióng fǎn zāo sú yǎn bái shì shàng wèi yǒu rú gōng pín dàn kàn gǔ lái shèng míng xià zhōng rì kǎn lǎn chán qí shēn","poem_text":"将军魏武之子孙，于今为庶为清门。\n英雄割据虽已矣，文采风流今尚存。\n学书初学卫夫人，但恨无过王右军。\n丹青不知老将至，富贵于我如浮云。\n开元之中常引见，承恩数上南薰殿。\n凌烟功臣少颜色，将军下笔开生面。\n良相头上进贤冠，猛将腰间大羽箭。\n褒公鄂公毛发动，英姿飒爽来酣战。\n先帝天马玉花骢，画工如山貌不同。\n是日牵来赤墀下，迥立阊阖生长风。\n诏谓将军拂绢素，意匠惨澹经营中。\n斯须九重真龙出，一洗万古凡马空。\n玉花却在御榻上，榻上庭前屹相向。\n至尊含笑催赐金，圉人太仆皆惆怅。\n弟子韩干早入室，亦能画马穷殊相。\n干惟画肉不画骨，忍使骅骝气凋丧。\n将军画善盖有神，必逢佳士亦写真。\n即今漂泊干戈际，屡貌寻常行路人。\n途穷反遭俗眼白，世上未有如公贫。\n但看古来盛名下，终日坎壈缠其身。","has_poem_preface":false,"poem_preface":"","poem_preface_translation":"","poem_lines":[{"chars":[{"char":"将","pinyin":"jiāng","annotation_ref":0},{"char":"军","pinyin":"jūn","annotation_ref":8},{"char":"魏","pinyin":"wèi","annotation_ref":0},{"char":"武","pinyin":"wǔ","annotation_ref":4},{"char":"之","pinyin":"zhī","annotation_ref":0},{"char":"子","pinyin":"zǐ","annotation_ref":0},{"char":"孙","pinyin":"sūn","annotation_ref":0}],"translation":"","punctuation":"，","line_role":"body"},{"chars":[{"char":"于","pinyin":"yú","annotation_ref":0},{"char":"今","pinyin":"jīn","annotation_ref":0},{"char":"为","pinyin":"wéi","annotation_ref":0},{"char":"庶","pinyin":"shù","annotation_ref":5},{"char":"为","pinyin":"wéi","annotation_ref":0},{"char":"清","pinyin":"qīng","annotation_ref":0},{"char":"门","pinyin":"mén","annotation_ref":6}],"translation":"","punctuation":"。","line_role":"body"},{"chars":[{"char":"英","pinyin":"yīng","annotation_ref":0},{"char":"雄","pinyin":"xióng","annotation_ref":0},{"char":"割","pinyin":"gē","annotation_ref":0},{"char":"据","pinyin":"jù","annotation_ref":0},{"char":"虽","pinyin":"suī","annotation_ref":0},{"char":"已","pinyin":"yǐ","annotation_ref":0},{"char":"矣","pinyin":"yǐ","annotation_ref":0}],"translation":"","punctuation":"，","line_role":"body"},{"chars":[{"char":"文","pinyin":"wén","annotation_ref":0},{"char":"采","pinyin":"cǎi","annotation_ref":0},{"char":"风","pinyin":"fēng","annotation_ref":0},{"char":"流","pinyin":"liú","annotation_ref":0},{"char":"今","pinyin":"jīn","annotation_ref":0},{"char":"尚","pinyin":"shàng","annotation_ref":0},{"char":"存","pinyin":"cún","annotation_ref":0}],"translation":"","punctuation":"。","line_role":"body"},{"chars":[{"char":"学","pinyin":"xué","annotation_ref":0},{"char":"书","pinyin":"shū","annotation_ref":0},{"char":"初","pinyin":"chū","annotation_ref":0},{"char":"学","pinyin":"xué","annotation_ref":0},{"char":"卫","pinyin":"wèi","annotation_ref":0},{"char":"夫","pinyin":"fū","annotation_ref":0},{"char":"人","pinyin":"rén","annotation_ref":7}],"translation":"","punctuation":"，","line_role":"body"},{"chars":[{"char":"但","pinyin":"dàn","annotation_ref":0},{"char":"恨","pinyin":"hèn","annotation_ref":0},{"char":"无","pinyin":"wú","annotation_ref":0},{"char":"过","pinyin":"guò","annotation_ref":0},{"char":"王","pinyin":"wáng","annotation_ref":0},{"char":"右","pinyin":"yòu","annotation_ref":0},{"char":"军","pinyin":"jūn","annotation_ref":0}],"translation":"","punctuation":"。","line_role":"body"},{"chars":[{"char":"丹","pinyin":"dān","annotation_ref":0},{"char":"青","pinyin":"qīng","annotation_ref":1},{"char":"不","pinyin":"bù","annotation_ref":0},{"char":"知","pinyin":"zhī","annotation_ref":0},{"char":"老","pinyin":"lǎo","annotation_ref":0},{"char":"将","pinyin":"jiāng","annotation_ref":0},{"char":"至","pinyin":"zhì","annotation_ref":0}],"translation":"","punctuation":"，","line_role":"body"},{"chars":[{"char":"富","pinyin":"fù","annotation_ref":0},{"char":"贵","pinyin":"guì","annotation_ref":0},{"char":"于","pinyin":"yú","annotation_ref":0},{"char":"我","pinyin":"wǒ","annotation_ref":0},{"char":"如","pinyin":"rú","annotation_ref":0},{"char":"浮","pinyin":"fú","annotation_ref":0},{"char":"云","pinyin":"yún","annotation_ref":0}],"translation":"","punctuation":"。","line_role":"body"},{"chars":[{"char":"开","pinyin":"kāi","annotation_ref":0},{"char":"元","pinyin":"yuán","annotation_ref":9},{"char":"之","pinyin":"zhī","annotation_ref":0},{"char":"中","pinyin":"zhōng","annotation_ref":0},{"char":"常","pinyin":"cháng","annotation_ref":0},{"char":"引","pinyin":"yǐn","annotation_ref":2},{"char":"见","pinyin":"jiàn","annotation_ref":10}],"translation":"","punctuation":"，","line_role":"body"},{"chars":[{"char":"承","pinyin":"chéng","annotation_ref":0},{"char":"恩","pinyin":"ēn","annotation_ref":11},{"char":"数","pinyin":"shuò","annotation_ref":0},{"char":"上","pinyin":"shàng","annotation_ref":0},{"char":"南","pinyin":"nán","annotation_ref":0},{"char":"薰","pinyin":"xūn","annotation_ref":0},{"char":"殿","pinyin":"diàn","annotation_ref":0}],"translation":"","punctuation":"。","line_role":"body"},{"chars":[{"char":"凌","pinyin":"líng","annotation_ref":0},{"char":"烟","pinyin":"yān","annotation_ref":12},{"char":"功","pinyin":"gōng","annotation_ref":0},{"char":"臣","pinyin":"chén","annotation_ref":0},{"char":"少","pinyin":"shǎo","annotation_ref":0},{"char":"颜","pinyin":"yán","annotation_ref":0},{"char":"色","pinyin":"sè","annotation_ref":0}],"translation":"","punctuation":"，","line_role":"body"},{"chars":[{"char":"将","pinyin":"jiāng","annotation_ref":0},{"char":"军","pinyin":"jūn","annotation_ref":0},{"char":"下","pinyin":"xià","annotation_ref":0},{"char":"笔","pinyin":"bǐ","annotation_ref":0},{"char":"开","pinyin":"kāi","annotation_ref":0},{"char":"生","pinyin":"shēng","annotation_ref":0},{"char":"面","pinyin":"miàn","annotation_ref":13}],"translation":"","punctuation":"。","line_role":"body"},{"chars":[{"char":"良","pinyin":"liáng","annotation_ref":0},{"char":"相","pinyin":"xiàng","annotation_ref":32},{"char":"头","pinyin":"tóu","annotation_ref":0},{"char":"上","pinyin":"shàng","annotation_ref":0},{"char":"进","pinyin":"jìn","annotation_ref":0},{"char":"贤","pinyin":"xián","annotation_ref":0},{"char":"冠","pinyin":"guān","annotation_ref":14}],"translation":"","punctuation":"，","line_role":"body"},{"chars":[{"char":"猛","pinyin":"měng","annotation_ref":0},{"char":"将","pinyin":"jiàng","annotation_ref":0},{"char":"腰","pinyin":"yāo","annotation_ref":0},{"char":"间","pinyin":"jiān","annotation_ref":0},{"char":"大","pinyin":"dà","annotation_ref":0},{"char":"羽","pinyin":"yǔ","annotation_ref":0},{"char":"箭","pinyin":"jiàn","annotation_ref":15}],"translation":"","punctuation":"。","line_role":"body"},{"chars":[{"char":"褒","pinyin":"bāo","annotation_ref":0},{"char":"公","pinyin":"gōng","annotation_ref":17},{"char":"鄂","pinyin":"è","annotation_ref":0},{"char":"公","pinyin":"gōng","annotation_ref":16},{"char":"毛","pinyin":"máo","annotation_ref":0},{"char":"发","pinyin":"fà","annotation_ref":0},{"char":"动","pinyin":"dòng","annotation_ref":0}],"translation":"","punctuation":"，","line_role":"body"},{"chars":[{"char":"英","pinyin":"yīng","annotation_ref":0},{"char":"姿","pinyin":"zī","annotation_ref":0},{"char":"飒","pinyin":"sà","annotation_ref":0},{"char":"爽","pinyin":"shuǎng","annotation_ref":0},{"char":"来","pinyin":"lái","annotation_ref":0},{"char":"酣","pinyin":"hān","annotation_ref":0},{"char":"战","pinyin":"zhàn","annotation_ref":0}],"translation":"","punctuation":"。","line_role":"body"},{"chars":[{"char":"先","pinyin":"xiān","annotation_ref":0},{"char":"帝","pinyin":"dì","annotation_ref":18},{"char":"天","pinyin":"tiān","annotation_ref":0},{"char":"马","pinyin":"mǎ","annotation_ref":0},{"char":"玉","pinyin":"yù","annotation_ref":0},{"char":"花","pinyin":"huā","annotation_ref":0},{"char":"骢","pinyin":"cōng","annotation_ref":19}],"translation":"","punctuation":"，","line_role":"body"},{"chars":[{"char":"画","pinyin":"huà","annotation_ref":0},{"char":"工","pinyin":"gōng","annotation_ref":0},{"char":"如","pinyin":"rú","annotation_ref":0},{"char":"山","pinyin":"shān","annotation_ref":20},{"char":"貌","pinyin":"mào","annotation_ref":36},{"char":"不","pinyin":"bù","annotation_ref":0},{"char":"同","pinyin":"tóng","annotation_ref":21}],"translation":"","punctuation":"。","line_role":"body"},{"chars":[{"char":"是","pinyin":"shì","annotation_ref":0},{"char":"日","pinyin":"rì","annotation_ref":0},{"char":"牵","pinyin":"qiān","annotation_ref":0},{"char":"来","pinyin":"lái","annotation_ref":0},{"char":"赤","pinyin":"chì","annotation_ref":0},{"char":"墀","pinyin":"chí","annotation_ref":22},{"char":"下","pinyin":"xià","annotation_ref":0}],"translation":"","punctuation":"，","line_role":"body"},{"chars":[{"char":"迥","pinyin":"jiǒng","annotation_ref":0},{"char":"立","pinyin":"lì","annotation_ref":0},{"char":"阊","pinyin":"chāng","annotation_ref":0},{"char":"阖","pinyin":"hé","annotation_ref":23},{"char":"生","pinyin":"shēng","annotation_ref":0},{"char":"长","pinyin":"cháng","annotation_ref":0},{"char":"风","pinyin":"fēng","annotation_ref":0}],"translation":"","punctuation":"。","line_role":"body"},{"chars":[{"char":"诏","pinyin":"zhào","annotation_ref":24},{"char":"谓","pinyin":"wèi","annotation_ref":0},{"char":"将","pinyin":"jiāng","annotation_ref":0},{"char":"军","pinyin":"jūn","annotation_ref":0},{"char":"拂","pinyin":"fú","annotation_ref":0},{"char":"绢","pinyin":"juàn","annotation_ref":0},{"char":"素","pinyin":"sù","annotation_ref":0}],"translation":"","punctuation":"，","line_role":"body"},{"chars":[{"char":"意","pinyin":"yì","annotation_ref":0},{"char":"匠","pinyin":"jiàng","annotation_ref":25},{"char":"惨","pinyin":"cǎn","annotation_ref":0},{"char":"澹","pinyin":"dàn","annotation_ref":26},{"char":"经","pinyin":"jīng","annotation_ref":0},{"char":"营","pinyin":"yíng","annotation_ref":27},{"char":"中","pinyin":"zhōng","annotation_ref":0}],"translation":"","punctuation":"。","line_role":"body"},{"chars":[{"char":"斯","pinyin":"sī","annotation_ref":0},{"char":"须","pinyin":"xū","annotation_ref":0},{"char":"九","pinyin":"jiǔ","annotation_ref":0},{"char":"重","pinyin":"chóng","annotation_ref":28},{"char":"真","pinyin":"zhēn","annotation_ref":34},{"char":"龙","pinyin":"lóng","annotation_ref":0},{"char":"出","pinyin":"chū","annotation_ref":0}],"translation":"","punctuation":"，","line_role":"body"},{"chars":[{"char":"一","pinyin":"yì","annotation_ref":0},{"char":"洗","pinyin":"xǐ","annotation_ref":0},{"char":"万","pinyin":"wàn","annotation_ref":0},{"char":"古","pinyin":"gǔ","annotation_ref":0},{"char":"凡","pinyin":"fán","annotation_ref":0},{"char":"马","pinyin":"mǎ","annotation_ref":0},{"char":"空","pinyin":"kōng","annotation_ref":0}],"translation":"","punctuation":"。","line_role":"body"},{"chars":[{"char":"玉","pinyin":"yù","annotation_ref":0},{"char":"花","pinyin":"huā","annotation_ref":0},{"char":"却","pinyin":"què","annotation_ref":0},{"char":"在","pinyin":"zài","annotation_ref":0},{"char":"御","pinyin":"yù","annotation_ref":0},{"char":"榻","pinyin":"tà","annotation_ref":0},{"char":"上","pinyin":"shàng","annotation_ref":0}],"translation":"","punctuation":"，","line_role":"body"},{"chars":[{"char":"榻","pinyin":"tà","annotation_ref":0},{"char":"上","pinyin":"shàng","annotation_ref":0},{"char":"庭","pinyin":"tíng","annotation_ref":0},{"char":"前","pinyin":"qián","annotation_ref":0},{"char":"屹","pinyin":"yì","annotation_ref":0},{"char":"相","pinyin":"xiāng","annotation_ref":0},{"char":"向","pinyin":"xiàng","annotation_ref":0}],"translation":"","punctuation":"。","line_role":"body"},{"chars":[{"char":"至","pinyin":"zhì","annotation_ref":0},{"char":"尊","pinyin":"zūn","annotation_ref":0},{"char":"含","pinyin":"hán","annotation_ref":0},{"char":"笑","pinyin":"xiào","annotation_ref":0},{"char":"催","pinyin":"cuī","annotation_ref":0},{"char":"赐","pinyin":"cì","annotation_ref":0},{"char":"金","pinyin":"jīn","annotation_ref":0}],"translation":"","punctuation":"，","line_role":"body"},{"chars":[{"char":"圉","pinyin":"yǔ","annotation_ref":0},{"char":"人","pinyin":"rén","annotation_ref":29},{"char":"太","pinyin":"tài","annotation_ref":0},{"char":"仆","pinyin":"pú","annotation_ref":30},{"char":"皆","pinyin":"jiē","annotation_ref":0},{"char":"惆","pinyin":"chóu","annotation_ref":0},{"char":"怅","pinyin":"chàng","annotation_ref":0}],"translation":"","punctuation":"。","line_role":"body"},{"chars":[{"char":"弟","pinyin":"dì","annotation_ref":0},{"char":"子","pinyin":"zǐ","annotation_ref":0},{"char":"韩","pinyin":"hán","annotation_ref":0},{"char":"干","pinyin":"gàn","annotation_ref":31},{"char":"早","pinyin":"zǎo","annotation_ref":0},{"char":"入","pinyin":"rù","annotation_ref":0},{"char":"室","pinyin":"shì","annotation_ref":0}],"translation":"","punctuation":"，","line_role":"body"},{"chars":[{"char":"亦","pinyin":"yì","annotation_ref":0},{"char":"能","pinyin":"néng","annotation_ref":0},{"char":"画","pinyin":"huà","annotation_ref":0},{"char":"马","pinyin":"mǎ","annotation_ref":0},{"char":"穷","pinyin":"qióng","annotation_ref":0},{"char":"殊","pinyin":"shū","annotation_ref":0},{"char":"相","pinyin":"xiàng","annotation_ref":0}],"translation":"","punctuation":"。","line_role":"body"},{"chars":[{"char":"干","pinyin":"gàn","annotation_ref":0},{"char":"惟","pinyin":"wéi","annotation_ref":0},{"char":"画","pinyin":"huà","annotation_ref":0},{"char":"肉","pinyin":"ròu","annotation_ref":0},{"char":"不","pinyin":"bú","annotation_ref":0},{"char":"画","pinyin":"huà","annotation_ref":0},{"char":"骨","pinyin":"gǔ","annotation_ref":0}],"translation":"","punctuation":"，","line_role":"body"},{"chars":[{"char":"忍","pinyin":"rěn","annotation_ref":0},{"char":"使","pinyin":"shǐ","annotation_ref":0},{"char":"骅","pinyin":"huá","annotation_ref":0},{"char":"骝","pinyin":"liú","annotation_ref":0},{"char":"气","pinyin":"qì","annotation_ref":0},{"char":"凋","pinyin":"diāo","annotation_ref":0},{"char":"丧","pinyin":"sàng","annotation_ref":0}],"translation":"","punctuation":"。","line_role":"body"},{"chars":[{"char":"将","pinyin":"jiāng","annotation_ref":0},{"char":"军","pinyin":"jūn","annotation_ref":0},{"char":"画","pinyin":"huà","annotation_ref":0},{"char":"善","pinyin":"shàn","annotation_ref":0},{"char":"盖","pinyin":"gài","annotation_ref":0},{"char":"有","pinyin":"yǒu","annotation_ref":0},{"char":"神","pinyin":"shén","annotation_ref":33}],"translation":"","punctuation":"，","line_role":"body"},{"chars":[{"char":"必","pinyin":"bì","annotation_ref":0},{"char":"逢","pinyin":"féng","annotation_ref":0},{"char":"佳","pinyin":"jiā","annotation_ref":0},{"char":"士","pinyin":"shì","annotation_ref":0},{"char":"亦","pinyin":"yì","annotation_ref":0},{"char":"写","pinyin":"xiě","annotation_ref":0},{"char":"真","pinyin":"zhēn","annotation_ref":0}],"translation":"","punctuation":"。","line_role":"body"},{"chars":[{"char":"即","pinyin":"jí","annotation_ref":0},{"char":"今","pinyin":"jīn","annotation_ref":0},{"char":"漂","pinyin":"piāo","annotation_ref":0},{"char":"泊","pinyin":"bó","annotation_ref":0},{"char":"干","pinyin":"gān","annotation_ref":0},{"char":"戈","pinyin":"gē","annotation_ref":35},{"char":"际","pinyin":"jì","annotation_ref":0}],"translation":"","punctuation":"，","line_role":"body"},{"chars":[{"char":"屡","pinyin":"lǚ","annotation_ref":0},{"char":"貌","pinyin":"mào","annotation_ref":0},{"char":"寻","pinyin":"xún","annotation_ref":0},{"char":"常","pinyin":"cháng","annotation_ref":0},{"char":"行","pinyin":"xíng","annotation_ref":0},{"char":"路","pinyin":"lù","annotation_ref":0},{"char":"人","pinyin":"rén","annotation_ref":0}],"translation":"","punctuation":"。","line_role":"body"},{"chars":[{"char":"途","pinyin":"tú","annotation_ref":0},{"char":"穷","pinyin":"qióng","annotation_ref":0},{"char":"反","pinyin":"fǎn","annotation_ref":0},{"char":"遭","pinyin":"zāo","annotation_ref":0},{"char":"俗","pinyin":"sú","annotation_ref":0},{"char":"眼","pinyin":"yǎn","annotation_ref":0},{"char":"白","pinyin":"bái","annotation_ref":0}],"translation":"","punctuation":"，","line_role":"body"},{"chars":[{"char":"世","pinyin":"shì","annotation_ref":0},{"char":"上","pinyin":"shàng","annotation_ref":0},{"char":"未","pinyin":"wèi","annotation_ref":0},{"char":"有","pinyin":"yǒu","annotation_ref":0},{"char":"如","pinyin":"rú","annotation_ref":0},{"char":"公","pinyin":"gōng","annotation_ref":0},{"char":"贫","pinyin":"pín","annotation_ref":0}],"translation":"","punctuation":"。","line_role":"body"},{"chars":[{"char":"但","pinyin":"dàn","annotation_ref":0},{"char":"看","pinyin":"kàn","annotation_ref":0},{"char":"古","pinyin":"gǔ","annotation_ref":0},{"char":"来","pinyin":"lái","annotation_ref":0},{"char":"盛","pinyin":"shèng","annotation_ref":0},{"char":"名","pinyin":"míng","annotation_ref":0},{"char":"下","pinyin":"xià","annotation_ref":0}],"translation":"","punctuation":"，","line_role":"body"},{"chars":[{"char":"终","pinyin":"zhōng","annotation_ref":0},{"char":"日","pinyin":"rì","annotation_ref":0},{"char":"坎","pinyin":"kǎn","annotation_ref":0},{"char":"壈","pinyin":"lǎn","annotation_ref":37},{"char":"缠","pinyin":"chán","annotation_ref":0},{"char":"其","pinyin":"qí","annotation_ref":0},{"char":"身","pinyin":"shēn","annotation_ref":0}],"translation":"","punctuation":"。","line_role":"body"}],"poem_variants":[{"variant_key":"standard","variant_label":"通行本","variant_source":"guwendao","poem_text":"将军魏武之子孙，于今为庶为清门。\n英雄割据虽已矣，文采风流今尚存。\n学书初学卫夫人，但恨无过王右军。\n丹青不知老将至，富贵于我如浮云。\n开元之中常引见，承恩数上南薰殿。\n凌烟功臣少颜色，将军下笔开生面。\n良相头上进贤冠，猛将腰间大羽箭。\n褒公鄂公毛发动，英姿飒爽来酣战。\n先帝天马玉花骢，画工如山貌不同。\n是日牵来赤墀下，迥立阊阖生长风。\n诏谓将军拂绢素，意匠惨澹经营中。\n斯须九重真龙出，一洗万古凡马空。\n玉花却在御榻上，榻上庭前屹相向。\n至尊含笑催赐金，圉人太仆皆惆怅。\n弟子韩干早入室，亦能画马穷殊相。\n干惟画肉不画骨，忍使骅骝气凋丧。\n将军画善盖有神，必逢佳士亦写真。\n即今漂泊干戈际，屡貌寻常行路人。\n途穷反遭俗眼白，世上未有如公贫。\n但看古来盛名下，终日坎壈缠其身。","pinyin":"jiāng jūn wèi wǔ zhī zǐ sūn yú jīn wéi shù wéi qīng mén yīng xióng gē jù suī yǐ yǐ wén cǎi fēng liú jīn shàng cún xué shū chū xué wèi fū rén dàn hèn wú guò wáng yòu jūn dān qīng bù zhī lǎo jiāng zhì fù guì yú wǒ rú fú yún kāi yuán zhī zhōng cháng yǐn jiàn chéng ēn shuò shàng nán xūn diàn líng yān gōng chén shǎo yán sè jiāng jūn xià bǐ kāi shēng miàn liáng xiàng tóu shàng jìn xián guān měng jiàng yāo jiān dà yǔ jiàn bāo gōng è gōng máo fà dòng yīng zī sà shuǎng lái hān zhàn xiān dì tiān mǎ yù huā cōng huà gōng rú shān mào bù tóng shì rì qiān lái chì chí xià jiǒng lì chāng hé shēng cháng fēng zhào wèi jiāng jūn fú juàn sù yì jiàng cǎn dàn jīng yíng zhōng sī xū jiǔ chóng zhēn lóng chū yì xǐ wàn gǔ fán mǎ kōng yù huā què zài yù tà shàng tà shàng tíng qián yì xiāng xiàng zhì zūn hán xiào cuī cì jīn yǔ rén tài pú jiē chóu chàng dì zǐ hán gàn zǎo rù shì yì néng huà mǎ qióng shū xiàng gàn wéi huà ròu bú huà gǔ rěn shǐ huá liú qì diāo sàng jiāng jūn huà shàn gài yǒu shén bì féng jiā shì yì xiě zhēn jí jīn piāo bó gān gē jì lǚ mào xún cháng xíng lù rén tú qióng fǎn zāo sú yǎn bái shì shàng wèi yǒu rú gōng pín dàn kàn gǔ lái shèng míng xià zhōng rì kǎn lǎn chán qí shēn","variant_notes":[]}],"translation":"曹将军是魏武帝曹操后代子孙，而今却沦为平民百姓成为寒门。\n英雄割据的时代一去不复返了，曹家文章丰采却在你身上留存。\n当年为学书法你先效仿卫夫人的风格，只恨得没有超过王羲之右将军。\n你毕生专攻绘画不知老之将至，荣华富贵对于你却如空中浮云。\n开元年间你常常被唐玄宗召见，承恩载德你曾多次登上南薰殿。\n凌烟阁的功臣画象年久褪颜色，曹将军你挥笔重画又别开生面。\n良相们的头顶都戴上了进贤冠，猛将们的腰间皆佩带着大羽箭。\n褒公鄂公的毛发似乎都在抖动，他们英姿飒爽好像是正在酣战。\n开元时先帝的天马名叫玉花骢，多少画家画出的都与原貌不同。\n当天玉花骢被牵到殿中红阶下，昂首屹立宫门更增添它的威风。\n皇上命令你丝绢准备作画，你先用浅淡颜色勾画出轮廓，然后苦心图绘。\n片刻间九天龙马就在绢上显现，一下比得万代凡马皆成了平庸。\n玉花骢图如真马倒在皇帝榻上，榻上的骏马与庭前的真马，昂首屹立两两相对。\n皇上含笑催促左右赏赐你黄金，太仆和马倌们个个都迷惘发怔。\n将军的门生韩干画技早学上手，他也能画马且有许多不凡形象。\n韩干只画外表画不出内在精神，常使骅骝好马的生气凋敝失丧。\n将军的画精美美在画中有神韵，偶逢真名士才肯为他动笔写真。\n而今你漂泊沦落在战乱的社会，平常所画的却是普通的行路人。\n你到晚年反而遭受世俗的白眼，人世间还未有人像你这般赤贫。\n只要看看历来那些负盛名的人，最终已经坎坷穷愁纠缠其身了。","translation_lines":["曹将军是魏武帝曹操后代子孙，","而今却沦为平民百姓成为寒门。","英雄割据的时代一去不复返了，","曹家文章丰采却在你身上留存。","当年为学书法你先效仿卫夫人的风格，","只恨得没有超过王羲之右将军。","你毕生专攻绘画不知老之将至，","荣华富贵对于你却如空中浮云。","开元年间你常常被唐玄宗召见，","承恩载德你曾多次登上南薰殿。","凌烟阁的功臣画象年久褪颜色，","曹将军你挥笔重画又别开生面。","良相们的头顶都戴上了进贤冠，","猛将们的腰间皆佩带着大羽箭。","褒公鄂公的毛发似乎都在抖动，","他们英姿飒爽好像是正在酣战。","开元时先帝的天马名叫玉花骢，","多少画家画出的都与原貌不同。","当天玉花骢被牵到殿中红阶下，","昂首屹立宫门更增添它的威风。","皇上命令你丝绢准备作画，","你先用浅淡颜色勾画出轮廓，然后苦心图绘。","片刻间九天龙马就在绢上显现，","一下比得万代凡马皆成了平庸。","玉花骢图如真马倒在皇帝榻上，","榻上的骏马与庭前的真马，昂首屹立两两相对。","皇上含笑催促左右赏赐你黄金，","太仆和马倌们个个都迷惘发怔。","将军的门生韩干画技早学上手，","他也能画马且有许多不凡形象。","韩干只画外表画不出内在精神，","常使骅骝好马的生气凋敝失丧。","将军的画精美美在画中有神韵，","偶逢真名士才肯为他动笔写真。","而今你漂泊沦落在战乱的社会，","平常所画的却是普通的行路人。","你到晚年反而遭受世俗的白眼，","人世间还未有人像你这般赤贫。","只要看看历来那些负盛名的人，","最终已经坎坷穷愁纠缠其身了。"],"annotations":[{"id":1,"term":"丹青","explanation":"指绘画"},{"id":2,"term":"引","explanation":"古时诗歌的一种体裁"},{"id":3,"term":"曹霸","explanation":"唐代名画家，以画人物及马著称，颇得唐高宗的宠幸，官至左武卫将军，故称他曹将军"},{"id":4,"term":"魏武","explanation":"指魏武帝曹操"},{"id":5,"term":"庶","explanation":"即庶人、平民"},{"id":6,"term":"清门","explanation":"即寒门，清贫之家"},{"id":7,"term":"卫夫人","explanation":"名铄，字茂猗"},{"id":8,"term":"王右军","explanation":"即晋代书法家王羲之，官至右军将军"},{"id":9,"term":"开元","explanation":"唐玄宗的年号(713年—741年)"},{"id":10,"term":"引见","explanation":"皇帝召见臣属"},{"id":11,"term":"承恩","explanation":"获得皇帝的恩宠"},{"id":12,"term":"凌烟","explanation":"即凌烟阁，唐太宗为了褒奖文武开国功臣，于贞观十七年命阎立本等在凌烟阁画二十四功臣图"},{"id":13,"term":"开生面","explanation":"展现出如生的面貌"},{"id":14,"term":"进贤冠","explanation":"古代成名，文儒者之服"},{"id":15,"term":"大羽箭","explanation":"大杆长箭"},{"id":16,"term":"褒公","explanation":"即段志玄、封褒国公"},{"id":17,"term":"鄂公","explanation":"即尉迟敬德，封鄂国公"},{"id":18,"term":"先帝","explanation":"指唐玄宗"},{"id":19,"term":"五花骢","explanation":"玄宗所骑的骏马名"},{"id":20,"term":"山","explanation":"众多的意思"},{"id":21,"term":"貌不同","explanation":"画得不—样，即画得不像"},{"id":22,"term":"赤墀","explanation":"也叫丹墀"},{"id":23,"term":"阊阖","explanation":"宫门"},{"id":24,"term":"诏","explanation":"皇帝的命令"},{"id":25,"term":"意匠","explanation":"指画家的立意和构思"},{"id":26,"term":"惨澹","explanation":"费心良苦"},{"id":27,"term":"经营","explanation":"即绘画的“经营位置 ，结构安排"},{"id":28,"term":"九重","explanation":"代指皇宫，因天子有九重门"},{"id":29,"term":"圉人","explanation":"管理御马的官吏"},{"id":30,"term":"太仆","explanation":"管理皇帝车马的官吏"},{"id":31,"term":"韩干","explanation":"唐代名画家"},{"id":32,"term":"穷殊相","explanation":"极尽各种不同的形姿变化"},{"id":33,"term":"盖有神","explanation":"大概有神明之助，极言曹霸画艺高超"},{"id":34,"term":"写真","explanation":"指画肖像"},{"id":35,"term":"干戈","explanation":"战争，当指安史之乱"},{"id":36,"term":"貌","explanation":"即写真"},{"id":37,"term":"坎壈","explanation":"贫困潦倒"}],"appreciation":"曹霸是盛唐著名画马大师，安史之乱后，潦倒漂泊。唐代宗广德二年（764），杜甫和他在成都相识，十分同情他的遭遇，写下这首《丹青引》。 诗起笔洗炼，苍凉。先说曹霸是魏武帝曹操之后，如今削籍，沦为寻常百姓。然后宕开一笔，颂扬曹霸祖先，曹操称雄中原的业绩虽成往史；但其诗歌的艺术造诣高超，辞采美妙，流风余韵，至今犹存。开头四句，抑扬起伏，跌宕多姿，大气包举，统摄全篇。清诗人王士禛十分赞赏，称为“工于发端”（《渔洋诗话》 接着写曹霸在书画上的师承渊源，进取精神，刻苦态度和高尚情操。曹霸最初学东晋卫夫人的书法，写得一手好字，只恨不能超过王羲之。他一生沉浸在绘画艺术之中而不知老之将至，情操高尚，不慕荣利，把功名富贵看得如天上浮云一般淡薄。诗人笔姿灵活，“学书”二句只是陪笔，故意一放；“丹青”二句点题，才是正意所在，写得主次分明，抑扬顿挫，错落有致。 “开元”以下八句，转入主题，高度赞扬曹霸在人物画上的辉煌成就。开元年间，曹霸应诏去见唐玄宗，有幸屡次登上南薰殿。凌烟阁上的功臣像，因年久褪色，曹霸奉命重绘。他以生花妙笔画得栩栩如生。文臣头戴朝冠，武将腰插大竿长箭。褒国公段志玄、鄂国公尉迟敬德，毛发飞动，神采奕奕，仿佛呼之欲出，要奔赴沙场鏖战一番似的。曹霸的肖像画，形神兼备，气韵生动，表现了高超的技艺。 诗人一层层写来，在这里，画人仍是衬笔，画马才是重点所在。“先帝”以下八句，诗人细腻地描写了画玉花骢的过程。 唐玄宗的御马玉花骢，众多画师都描摹过，各各不同，无一肖似逼真。有一天，玉花骢牵至阊阖宫的赤色台阶前，扬首卓立，神气轩昂。玄宗即命曹霸白绢当场写生。作画前曹霸先巧妙运思，然后淋漓尽致地落笔挥洒，须臾之间，一气呵成。那画马神奇雄峻，好象从宫门腾跃而出的飞龙，一切凡马在此马前都不免相形失色。诗人先用“生长风”形容真马的雄骏神气，作为画马的有力陪衬，再用众画工的凡马来烘托画师的“真龙”，着意描摹曹霸画马的神妙，这一段文字倾注了热烈赞美之情，笔墨酣畅，精彩之极。“玉花”以下八句，诗人进而形容画马的艺术魅力。 榻上放着画马玉花骢，乍一看，似和殿前真马两两相对，昂首屹立。诗人把画马与真马合写，实在高妙，不着一“肖”字，却极为生动地写出了画马的逼真传神，令人真假莫辨。玄宗看到画马神态轩昂，十分高兴，含笑催促侍从，赶快赐金奖赏。掌管朝廷车马的官员和养马人都不胜感慨，怅然若失。杜甫以玄宗、太仆和圉人的不同反应渲染出曹霸画技的高妙超群。随后又用他的弟子、也以画马有名的韩干来作反衬。 诗人用前后对比的手法，以浓墨彩笔铺叙曹霸过去在宫廷作画的盛况；最后八句，又以苍凉的笔调描写曹霸如今流入民间的落泊境况。“将军善画盖有神”句，总收上文，点明曹霸画艺的精湛绝伦。他不轻易为人画像。可是，在战乱的动荡岁月里，一代画马宗师，流落飘泊，竟不得不靠卖画为生，甚至屡屡为寻常过路行人画像了。曹霸走投无路，遭到流俗的轻视，生活如此穷苦，世上没有比他更贫困的了。画家的辛酸境遇和杜甫的坎坷蹭蹬又何其相似！诗人内心不禁引起共鸣，感慨万分：自古负有盛名、成就杰出的艺术家，往往时运不济，困顿缠身，郁郁不得志！诗的结句，推开一层讲，以此宽解曹霸，同时也聊以自慰，饱含对封建社会世态炎凉的愤慨。 这首诗在章法上错综绝妙，诗中宾主分明，对比强烈。如学书与学画，画人与画马，真马与画马，凡马与“真龙”，画工与曹霸，韩干与曹霸，昔日之盛与今日之衰等等。前者为宾，是绿叶，后者为主，是红花。绿叶扶红花，烘托映衬，红花见得更为突出而鲜明。在诗情发展上，抑扬起伏，波澜层出。前四句写曹霸的身世，包含两层抑扬，摇曳多姿。“至尊含笑催赐金”句，将全诗推向高潮，一起后紧跟着一跌，与末段“途穷反遭俗眼白”，又形成尖锐的对比。诗的结构，一抑一扬地波浪式，最后以抑的沉郁调子结束，显得错综变化而又多样统一。在结构上，前后呼应，首尾相连。诗的开头“于今为庶为清门”与结尾“世上未有如公贫”，一脉贯通，构成一种悲慨的主调与苍凉的气氛。中间三段，写曹霸画人画马的盛况，与首段“文采风流今尚存”句相照应。 杜甫以《丹青引》为题，热情地为画家立传，以诗摹写画意，评画论画，诗画结合，富有浓郁的诗情画意，把深邃的现实主义画论和诗传体的特写融为一炉，具有独特的美学意义，在中国唐代美术史和绘画批评史上也有一定的认识价值。这在唐诗的发展上未尝不是一种新贡献。","analysis":"《丹青引赠曹将军霸》是一首七言古诗，此诗赞颂曹霸善画。开头四句写曹霸的身世，统摄全篇；接着写其在书画上的师承渊源，进取精神，刻苦态度和高尚情操；“开元”以下八句，高度赞扬他在人物画上的辉煌成就；“先帝”以下八句，细腻地描写了画玉花骢的过程；“玉花”以下八句，进而形容画马的艺术魅力；最后八句，又以苍凉的笔调描写曹霸流入民间的落泊境况。全诗章法错综绝妙，诗情抑扬起伏，摹写画意、评画论画，诗画结合，富有诗情画意，把深邃的现实主义画论和诗传体的特写熔为一炉，具有独特的美学意义。","background":"曹霸是盛唐时期的画马大师，成名于唐玄宗开元年间。天宝年间曾画“御马”，并修补凌烟阁功臣像。唐玄宗末年得罪，削籍为庶人。安史之乱后，潦倒漂泊。唐代宗广德二年（764），杜甫和曹霸在成都相识，十分同情曹霸的遭遇，写下了这首《丹青引赠曹将军霸》。","author_bio":"杜甫（712－770），字子美，自号少陵野老，世称“杜工部”、“杜少陵”等，汉族，河南府巩县（今河南省巩义市）人，唐代伟大的现实主义诗人，杜甫被世人尊为“诗圣”，其诗被称为“诗史”。杜甫与李白合称“李杜”，为了跟另外两位诗人李商隐与杜牧即“小李杜”区别开来，杜甫与李白又合称“大李杜”。他忧国忧民，人格高尚，他的约1400余首诗被保留了下来，诗艺精湛，在中国古典诗歌中备受推崇，影响深远。759-766年间曾居成都，后世有杜甫草堂纪念。","filter_tags":["唐诗三百首","中国诗词大会2024","中国诗词大会2023"],"canonical_url":"http://www.guwendao.net/shiwenv.aspx?id=0b8b1899dd68","audio":{"recite":["/audio/0b8b1899dd68/gushiwen_1.mp3"],"translation":["/audio/0b8b1899dd68/fanyi_1.mp3"],"appreciation":["/audio/0b8b1899dd68/shangxi_1.mp3","/audio/0b8b1899dd68/shangxi_2.mp3","/audio/0b8b1899dd68/shangxi_3.mp3"]},"weather_binding":{"primary_weather":"neutral","intensity":0,"time_of_day":"unknown","lighting":"neutral","wind":"unknown","temperature":"unknown","visibility":"unknown","surface":"unknown","extraction_method":"fallback","evidence":[],"confidence":"high","weather_sequence":null,"notes":"富贵于我如浮云为比喻；迥立阊阖生长风描写马的气势如生风，非真实天气。原诗无可确认的当前天气。","review_status":"pending"},"appreciation_versions":[{"version_name":"境界细读版","title":"境界细读：画马段五层推进如何让\"一洗万古凡马空\"成为必然","body":"## 一、核心判断\n\n读《丹青引赠曹将军霸》的人，多半会记住\"斯须九重真龙出，一洗万古凡马空\"这一联，并把它当成全诗最高亢的赞辞。可若是只把这一联单独拈出来夸，便辜负了杜甫的匠心。这两句之所以能立得住，是因为前面整整十二句都在为它搭台阶——难画铺垫、马本身难画、惨澹经营、斯须立就、凡马皆空，五层一层比一层陡，最后才让那句夸张变得不可质疑。\n\n我在这篇赏析里要讨论的，正是画马段这五层推进的内在结构。它不是堆景象，是搭阶梯。\n\n## 二、从关键诗句进入\n\n画马段从\"先帝天马玉花骢\"起笔。这第一句看似只是介绍画的对象，其实已经设下了第一道关隘。\n\n\"画工如山貌不同\"——玄宗爱这匹玉花骢，召来的画工如山如海，每个人画出来的马却都不一样。这一句的关键不在\"如山\"，在\"貌不同\"。画工多，恰恰说明没人画得像；若有一人画得像，后面就不必再请曹霸。所以这一句是第一层铺垫：玉花骢难画，难到一整代画工都画不像。\n\n可杜甫没急着让曹霸出场，他先补了一句：\"是日牵来赤墀下，迥立阊阖生长风。\"这是第二层铺垫，比第一层更深。第一层说画工画不出，第二层说为什么画不出——因为这匹马本身神采飞扬、昂首嘶鸣、立于宫门前仿佛自带疾风。难画不在形，在神；不在皮肉，在那一股\"生长风\"的势。前面画工画不像，到这里才有了具体原因：他们捕捉不到这股势。\n\n两层铺垫铺完，曹霸仍不出场。杜甫先让玄宗下诏：\"诏谓将军拂绢素\"——皇帝一声令下，曹霸这才登场。可登场之后，他还是不立刻下笔。\n\n## 三、诗意如何转深\n\n\"意匠惨澹经营中\"是第三层，写的是构思。曹霸在皇帝面前没有紧张，也没有逞能，他先凝神苦思，苦苦寻找合适的画法。\"惨澹\"二字要紧——这个古今异义词，今人容易误读成\"生意萧条\"，其实古义是费尽心思。曹霸的心血全在这一句里：他知道这匹马难画，他知道前人画不像的原因，所以他不肯草率下笔。一个画师在皇帝面前敢让笔停下来，是因为他更怕画不出神。\n\n到这里，节奏陡然加快。\"斯须九重真龙出\"——斯须，是不一会儿的功夫。构思那么久，落笔却这么快。这是第四层：苦思之后的爆发，凝神之后的释放。前面\"惨澹经营\"的慢，正是为了这一句\"斯须\"的快做反衬。九重真龙，既是画中马如龙自天而降，也是说这幅画从宫殿深处一跃而出。\n\n紧接着是第五层：\"一洗万古凡马空。\"——万古以来画马之作尽被这一洗而去，唯有这幅画中的马才是真龙。这一句的夸张到了顶点，可奇怪的是读者并不觉得夸张失实。原因就在前面四层铺垫：画工画不像、马本身难画、曹霸惨澹经营、斯须立就——每一层都在为这一句的夸张背书。等到这一句出来，读者已经被推到台阶的最高一级，不得不接受这个判断。\n\n杜甫还嫌不够，又补了\"玉花却在御榻上，榻上庭前屹相向\"两句作收束。画成的玉花骢放在御榻上，与庭前真马相对而立，仿佛两匹马互相望着——这是用画成之后的视觉对照再次验证\"真龙出\"。\"至尊含笑催赐金，圉人太仆皆惆怅\"——玄宗笑着赏金，养马驯马的官却一脸失落。这失落里既有一份\"自己辛苦养马反不及一画师受赏\"的酸楚，也有一份\"画中马竟与庭前马无异\"的震撼。两层情绪叠在一起，画马段才告收束。\n\n## 四、必要考据\n\n- \"玉花骢\"为玄宗内厩名马，骢指青白花色马。\"天马\"是汉血宝马的雅称，此处未必实指汉血，只是极言其骏。\n- \"赤墀\"是宫中染朱红色漆的台阶，\"阊阖\"本指天门，此处借指宫门。\"迥立阊阖生长风\"是写马立于宫门、昂首生风的姿态。\n- \"绢素\"本义未染色的丝织品，唐代画马多以绢本为载体，故今存唐画多为绢本。\n- \"惨澹经营\"古今异义，古义费尽心思，非今义\"生意萧条\"。杜甫此句是\"惨澹\"在唐诗中最有名的用例。\n- \"九重\"两说并存：一说指宫殿深邃，一说指天有九重。两说皆通，写作时不必强执一解。\n- \"圉人\"是养马的官，\"太仆\"是管理皇家车马的官，皆见《唐六典》太仆寺条。\n\n## 五、比较与定位\n\n可以拿韩干《照夜白图》做对照。韩干是曹霸弟子，今存《照夜白图》中那匹马拴在柱上、肥壮而嘶鸣，筋骨却被皮肉遮住——这正对应杜甫后文\"干惟画肉不画骨\"的评语。曹霸的画未传，但从杜甫这段描写看，他要画的是\"生长风\"的势、\"九重真龙\"的神，是马骨子里那一股不可见的骏——这恰是韩干所不到处。\n\n更能照亮本段的对照，是杜甫自己在《房兵曹胡马》里写过的\"竹批双耳峻，风入四蹄轻\"。那首诗写马也是写神，但写的是真马之神，落到具体的耳与蹄；《丹青引》写的是画中之马之神，落到的是\"榻上庭前屹相向\"的视觉对照。一真一画，杜甫对\"马之神\"的把握在两首诗里互为镜像。\n\n## 六、总评\n\n画马段二十句，是《丹青引》全诗最浓的一段，也是杜甫七古中结构最严密的一段之一。它的好不在\"一洗万古凡马空\"这一句夸张，而在前面四层铺垫让这夸张变得不可质疑；它的妙不在\"斯须九重真龙出\"的速，而在前面\"惨澹经营\"的慢。读这段诗，若只记住了那一联赞辞，就等于把一整段台阶看成了平地——杜甫搭阶梯的功夫，恰恰是这首诗最难学处。","assets":{"poem_id":"0b8b1899dd68","title":"丹青引赠曹将军霸","version_name":"境界细读版","appreciation_title":"境界细读：画马段五层推进如何让\"一洗万古凡马空\"成为必然","author":"杜甫","dynasty":"唐代","poem_text":"将军魏武之子孙，于今为庶为清门。\n英雄割据虽已矣，文采风流今尚存。\n学书初学卫夫人，但恨无过王右军。\n丹青不知老将至，富贵于我如浮云。\n开元之中常引见，承恩数上南薰殿。\n凌烟功臣少颜色，将军下笔开生面。\n良相头上进贤冠，猛将腰间大羽箭。\n褒公鄂公毛发动，英姿飒爽来酣战。\n先帝天马玉花骢，画工如山貌不同。\n是日牵来赤墀下，迥立阊阖生长风。\n诏谓将军拂绢素，意匠惨澹经营中。\n斯须九重真龙出，一洗万古凡马空。\n玉花却在御榻上，榻上庭前屹相向。\n至尊含笑催赐金，圉人太仆皆惆怅。\n弟子韩干早入室，亦能画马穷殊相。\n干惟画肉不画骨，忍使骅骝气凋丧。\n将军画善盖有神，必逢佳士亦写真。\n即今漂泊干戈际，屡貌寻常行路人。\n途穷反遭俗眼白，世上未有如公贫。\n但看古来盛名下，终日坎壈缠其身。","source_url":"https://www.bilibili.com/video/BV1st4y1b7PX","skill":"appreciate-tangshi","generated_at":"2026-07-02T17:50:29+00:00","public_dir":"/appreciation/0b8b1899dd68","article_path":"/appreciation/0b8b1899dd68/version-200a6dedd5.md","metadata_path":"/appreciation/0b8b1899dd68/version-200a6dedd5.metadata.json","transcript_path":"/appreciation/0b8b1899dd68/version-200a6dedd5.transcript.md","review_path":""},"source":{"type":"bilibili","url":"https://www.bilibili.com/video/BV1st4y1b7PX","transcript_file":"/Users/bupt_absinth/Work/projects/poetry/skill/appreciate_tangshi/bilibili/丹青引赠曹将军霸/BV1st4y1b7PX/merged_transcript.md"},"review":"","source_url":"https://www.bilibili.com/video/BV1st4y1b7PX","generated_at":"2026-07-02T17:50:29+00:00"},{"version_name":"兴发感动版","title":"兴发感动：两个穷困艺术家在成都街头相遇时写下的命运之诗","body":"## 一、核心判断\n\n读《丹青引赠曹将军霸》的人，多把注意力放在画技描写上——凌烟功臣、玉花骢、韩干对比——这些当然精彩。可这首诗真正让人心里动起来的地方，不在画技，而在末段那一句\"但看古来盛名下，终日坎壈缠其身\"。这一句既是劝曹霸，也是杜甫自况；既是劝慰，又是预测。两个伟大的艺术家在成都街头相遇，都已成老人，都陷入穷困，杜甫写曹霸的小传时，也写下了自己的命运。\n\n我在这篇赏析里要讨论的，正是这种双重身世感慨的兴发机制——它不是两句议论，是整首诗的结构在向这一句汇聚。\n\n## 二、从关键诗句进入\n\n要从\"富贵于我如浮云\"这一句进入。这一句出现在诗的前段，看上去是杜甫在夸曹霸专心绘画、不图富贵，是豁达之语。可若只读出豁达，便辜负了杜甫的笔法。\n\n\"富贵如浮云\"在《论语》本是君子轻视富贵之喻——\"不义而富且贵，于我如浮云\"。曹霸用在这里，自然是说他专心丹青、不慕荣利。可浮云还有一重意：浮云飘忽不定，不好把握。一个人说\"富贵于我如浮云\"，固然可以说是轻视，但反过来说，也暗示此人一生注定与富贵无缘——不是不想要，是抓不住。这一重无奈，曹霸未必自觉，杜甫写时未必不觉。\n\n更妙的是，这一句的语气不像杜甫日常沉郁的风格，倒有几分李白豪放不羁的影子。杜甫在送一位穷困画师时偏用这种语气，是把曹霸往豪杰一路写，也是把自己往豪杰一路写。两个落魄人之间，需要一种不流于自怜的语气撑住体面。这是诗人在穷途里给自己留的尊严。\n\n## 三、诗意如何转深\n\n豁达也好，无奈也罢，单看前段这一句还看不出分量。它真正的分量要到末段才显出来。\n\n\"即今漂泊干戈际，屡貌寻常行路人\"——画面突然从开元盛世的南薰殿、玉花骢，跳到安史乱后的蜀中街头。曹霸从为皇帝画功臣、画天马，落到给寻常路人画像糊口。这两句之间隔了几十年、几千里、一场大乱，杜甫只用\"即今\"二字就切过去了。这二字之重，几乎压垮前文所有的辉煌。\n\n\"途穷反遭俗眼白，世上未有如公贫\"——更惨的是，他不仅穷，还被人看不起。那些让他画像的寻常路人不知道这位老人曾为玄宗画过凌烟功臣、画过玉花骢，他们看他画得慢、画得不像他们想要的那种，便给他白眼。一个画过\"九重真龙\"的人，晚年要忍受不识货者的白眼——这才是穷途。这一句\"世上未有如公贫\"的\"贫\"字，要紧：贫的不是才华换不到钱，是才华在这个世道里彻底没有用武之地。\n\n到这里，前面\"富贵于我如浮云\"才显出真正的双重意。开头是曹霸的豁达，也是杜甫写时的预感；到末段，预感成了现实，豁达成了无奈。\n\n最深的兴发在末尾一句——\"但看古来盛名下，终日坎壈缠其身\"。古往今来身负盛名的人，有哪一个不是终生陷在困顿里？这一句有两层读法。第一层是劝曹霸：你今日的穷困不是你一个人的事，是身负盛名者的共业；把曹霸的遭遇放进一个更大的历史图式里，让他的痛苦不至于孤立。第二层是杜甫自况。杜甫写这首诗时自己也正穷困——他弃官入蜀、依附严武，靠人接济度日。他写\"古来盛名下，终日坎壈缠其身\"时，写的是曹霸，也是自己。更妙的是，这一句不仅是劝慰，还是预测：杜甫在世时确实困顿，身后却被尊为\"诗圣\"；曹霸的画虽未传，但杜甫这首诗让他的名字活到了今天。这一句像是杜甫写给自己的预言——他知道身后会有盛名，可他也知道盛名救不了当下。\n\n这种\"既是劝人又是自况、既是劝慰又是预测\"的双重结构，让末段这一句成了全诗最沉的支点。前面所有的画技描写、所有的辉煌回忆，到这里都被这一句压住——再大的才华、再高的画技，最终都要落在\"终日坎壈缠其身\"这七个字上。开头是预感，末段是现实；开头是豁达，末段是无奈——两层意合起来，才是这首诗真正的兴发机制。\n\n## 四、必要考据\n\n- 杜甫于乾元二年（759）弃官华州司功参军之职，辗转秦州、同谷入蜀，上元元年（760）起在成都西郊浣花溪畔建草堂。本诗约作于广德二年（764）前后，其时杜甫初入严武幕府为节度参谋，仍处穷困。\n- 曹霸于天宝间官至左武卫将军，安史乱前因罪被贬为庶民；乱后流落四川，以卖画为生。杜甫在成都街头与之相遇的具体年份，诸注家有广德二年（764）说与永泰元年（765）说，宜标\"约\"。\n- \"坎壈\"出王逸《楚辞章句》，意谓困顿不得志。杜甫此句用\"坎壈\"二字，是楚辞系统的语汇，分量比一般的\"贫困\"更重。\n- \"俗眼白\"用魏晋\"白眼\"典，指不识货者以白眼看人。曹霸晚年卖画，买画者多不知其曾为玄宗御用画师。\n- \"富贵于我如浮云\"出《论语·述而》\"不义而富且贵，于我如浮云\"，杜甫借用此句，把曹霸放进儒家君子的语谱里。\n\n## 五、比较与定位\n\n可以拿杜甫《观公孙大娘弟子舞剑器行》做对照。那首诗也是从开元盛世的辉煌回忆起笔，落到当下的衰飒——\"梨园弟子散如烟，女乐余姿映寒日\"。结构上与本诗相似：盛—衰—感慨。但《舞剑器行》收束在\"老夫不知其所往，足茧荒山转愁疾\"，是一份纯粹的漂泊之悲；《丹青引》收束在\"但看古来盛名下，终日坎壈缠其身\"，则把个人之悲抬到共业层面，由一己的坎壈推到所有盛名者的坎壈。这是杜甫晚年赠艺人之作的两副面目：一种悲止于个人，一种悲推到共业。\n\n更能照亮本诗的对照，是杜甫《江南逢李龟年》——\"岐王宅里寻常见，崔九堂前几度闻。正是江南好风景，落花时节又逢君。\"那首诗写的是另一位开元旧人在乱后的相逢，二十八字里不动声色地把盛唐转衰一笔带过。《丹青引》写的是同一种相逢，只是篇幅拉长、细节铺满、感慨说尽——一首短一首长，一首收一首放，可底子里的兴发机制是同一个：两个从盛世走来的老人，在乱世街头重逢，谁都没说什么，可谁都明白。\n\n## 六、总评\n\n《丹青引》最深的兴发，不在\"斯须九重真龙出，一洗万古凡马空\"的画技夸张，而在末段那一句把全诗的辉煌回忆都压下去的\"但看古来盛名下，终日坎壈缠其身\"。杜甫写曹霸，也是写自己；写当下，也是写身后的预言。两个伟大的艺术家在成都街头相遇，一个画过九重真龙，一个写过会当凌绝顶，此刻都成了\"世上未有如公贫\"里的\"公\"。这首诗让人心里动起来的地方，正是这种把个人之悲推到共业、把当下之困推到身后的笔法——它让一首赠人之作，变成了杜甫写给所有盛名者的祭文。","assets":{"poem_id":"0b8b1899dd68","title":"丹青引赠曹将军霸","version_name":"兴发感动版","appreciation_title":"兴发感动：两个穷困艺术家在成都街头相遇时写下的命运之诗","author":"杜甫","dynasty":"唐代","poem_text":"将军魏武之子孙，于今为庶为清门。\n英雄割据虽已矣，文采风流今尚存。\n学书初学卫夫人，但恨无过王右军。\n丹青不知老将至，富贵于我如浮云。\n开元之中常引见，承恩数上南薰殿。\n凌烟功臣少颜色，将军下笔开生面。\n良相头上进贤冠，猛将腰间大羽箭。\n褒公鄂公毛发动，英姿飒爽来酣战。\n先帝天马玉花骢，画工如山貌不同。\n是日牵来赤墀下，迥立阊阖生长风。\n诏谓将军拂绢素，意匠惨澹经营中。\n斯须九重真龙出，一洗万古凡马空。\n玉花却在御榻上，榻上庭前屹相向。\n至尊含笑催赐金，圉人太仆皆惆怅。\n弟子韩干早入室，亦能画马穷殊相。\n干惟画肉不画骨，忍使骅骝气凋丧。\n将军画善盖有神，必逢佳士亦写真。\n即今漂泊干戈际，屡貌寻常行路人。\n途穷反遭俗眼白，世上未有如公贫。\n但看古来盛名下，终日坎壈缠其身。","source_url":"https://www.bilibili.com/video/BV1st4y1b7PX","skill":"appreciate-tangshi","generated_at":"2026-07-02T17:57:24+00:00","public_dir":"/appreciation/0b8b1899dd68","article_path":"/appreciation/0b8b1899dd68/version-a0fc1592c3.md","metadata_path":"/appreciation/0b8b1899dd68/version-a0fc1592c3.metadata.json","transcript_path":"/appreciation/0b8b1899dd68/version-a0fc1592c3.transcript.md","review_path":""},"source":{"type":"bilibili","url":"https://www.bilibili.com/video/BV1st4y1b7PX","transcript_file":"/Users/bupt_absinth/Work/projects/poetry/skill/appreciate_tangshi/bilibili/丹青引赠曹将军霸/BV1st4y1b7PX/merged_transcript.md"},"review":"","source_url":"https://www.bilibili.com/video/BV1st4y1b7PX","generated_at":"2026-07-02T17:57:24+00:00"},{"version_name":"唐诗气象版","title":"唐诗气象：一位画师小传里藏着的盛唐转衰","body":"## 一、核心判断\n\n读《丹青引赠曹将军霸》最容易把它读成一首人物小传——曹霸的身世、画技、晚年落魄，一一写来，末了发几句感慨。这当然不错，但这样读便辜负了杜甫的野心。这首诗表面是赠画师的小传，骨子里是一首微缩的盛唐转衰史诗。前三段全在开元盛世的光辉里——曹霸是那个时代的受益者，玄宗的厚赏也代表那个时代的气象；后两段骤然转入安史乱后的破碎。杜甫借一位画师的一生，写出了一个时代的转折，并在其中隐伏对玄宗耽艺忘国的微词。\n\n我在这篇赏析里要讨论的，正是这种\"以一人写一代\"的气象学笔法——它让一首赠人之作，变成了一面照盛唐兴衰的镜子。\n\n## 二、从关键诗句进入\n\n要从\"开元之中常引见，承恩数上南薰殿\"这两句进入。这两句看似只是交代曹霸受宠的时间地点，其实已经把全诗的时代坐标定下来了——开元。\n\n开元是盛唐的极盛期。玄宗即位之初励精图治，姚崇、宋璟相继为相，府库充实、四夷宾服，史称\"开元之治\"。可在曹霸的故事里，开元是另一种气象：皇帝在南薰殿里接连召见一位画师，让画师重画凌烟功臣像，让画师为爱马玉花骢写真。这些事本身不算奢靡，可它们合在一起，指向的是另一种开元——一个皇帝开始有闲情、有雅好、有内厩名马、有工夫为一张画动容的盛世晚年。\n\n杜甫写这首诗时已经在安史乱后，回望开元，他的笔法是克制的。他不直说玄宗晚年耽于艺事，只让\"南薰殿\"\"凌烟阁\"\"玉花骢\"这些细节自己说话。可这份克制本身就是一种判断——一个皇帝召见画师的频率，比召见谏臣的频率还高，朝政气象如何，读诗者自知。\n\n## 三、诗意如何转深\n\n诗的气象转折发生在\"即今漂泊干戈际\"一句。\"干戈际\"三个字一出来，前面所有的辉煌立刻褪色。这是杜甫最擅长的笔法——不写战争本身，只写战争之后落到一个画师身上的余烬。\n\n曹霸本是开元盛世的宠儿——左武卫将军、南薰殿常客、为凌烟功臣重画、为玄宗爱马写真。这样一个人物，到\"干戈际\"三个字里，瞬间成了\"漂泊\"二字的注脚。前面四十句铺陈的辉煌，到这里被这一句一笔抹掉。这种\"一笔抹掉\"的笔法，是杜甫写盛唐转衰最深的功夫——他不写战乱的具体场面，他只写一个画师从南薰殿到蜀中街头的位移，整个时代的崩塌就在这个位移里。\n\n更妙的是\"屡貌寻常行路人\"。\"屡\"字要紧——不是偶一为之，是常常。一个曾为玄宗画玉花骢的画师，如今常常在街头给寻常路人画像。这\"寻常\"二字与前面的\"凌烟功臣\"\"先帝天马\"对得刺眼——画的对象从功臣天马落到寻常路人，画师的处境也从御前到街头。杜甫用一个\"屡\"字把这种落差写到了日常化、重复化、不可挽回的程度。这不是一时的潦倒，是从此以后的命运。\n\n到这里，前面\"开元之中常引见\"才显出真正的分量。开元盛世不是被外力一击而碎，它是从这种\"屡貌寻常行路人\"的日常化潦倒里慢慢褪色的。一个时代的结束，不在战场上，在一个画师日复一日给寻常路人画像的街头。\n\n## 四、必要考据\n\n- 开元（713—741）为唐玄宗年号，共二十九年。开元中前期国力鼎盛，史称\"开元之治\"；开元末至天宝间，玄宗渐耽享乐，朝政转向李林甫、杨国忠专权。\n- 南薰殿在兴庆宫内。兴庆宫原为玄宗为藩王时旧宅，即位后扩建为宫，玄宗常年居此。玄宗理政虽多在大明宫，兴庆宫是宴乐、艺事之所。\n- 凌烟阁画像为唐太宗贞观十七年（643）所立，画二十四功臣像，最初由阎立本绘制。开元中重修，命曹霸重绘。二十四功臣包括褒国公段志玄、鄂国公尉迟敬德等。\n- 玉花骢为玄宗内厩名马。唐代内厩养马盛时可达数十万匹，玄宗尤爱名马，命画工写真之事屡见史载。\n- 安史之乱起于天宝十四载（755），历时八年方平。乱后唐王朝由盛转衰，藩镇割据、宦官专权渐成常态。杜甫本人于乾元二年（759）弃官入蜀，本诗作于乱后蜀中。\n- 杜甫对玄宗的批评一向含蓄。《北征》《忆昔》诸作皆有微词，但不直斥。本诗\"圉人太仆皆惆怅\"一句，亦含对玄宗厚画师薄小臣的微讽，是杜诗\"沉郁顿挫\"风格的典型笔法。\n\n## 五、比较与定位\n\n可以拿杜甫《忆昔二首》之二做对照。那首诗正面写开元盛世——\"忆昔开元全盛日，小邑犹藏万家室。稻米流脂粟米白，公私仓廪俱丰实。\"句句是富庶的实景，是盛世气象的正面写法。可写到结尾，杜甫笔锋一转：\"周宣中兴望我皇，洒血江汉身衰疾。\"——盛世的回忆最后落在当下的衰病里。结构上与本诗相似：盛—衰—感慨，但《忆昔》是直陈，《丹青引》是借人。《忆昔》里的开元是数字与景象，《丹青引》里的开元是一个画师的命运——后者比前者更具体，也更沉痛。\n\n更能照亮本诗的对照，是白居易《长恨歌》开篇——\"汉皇重色思倾国，御宇多年求不得。杨家有女初长成，养在深闺人未识。\"《长恨歌》写玄宗耽色，《丹青引》写玄宗耽艺，两者都是盛世转衰的症候。但白居易写的是直陈的讽喻，杜甫写的是含蓄的微词——一个让玄宗自己出场，一个让玄宗只在\"南薰殿\"\"圉人太仆\"这些细节里露面。两种笔法两种气象，可底子里的判断是同一个：盛世的崩塌，往往从皇帝的某种\"耽\"开始。\n\n## 六、总评\n\n《丹青引》最深的气象学，不在前段的辉煌铺陈，也不在后段的潦倒直写，而在两者之间那一句\"即今漂泊干戈际\"的\"即今\"二字。这两个字像一把刀，把诗劈成两半——前面是开元的南薰殿、凌烟阁、玉花骢，后面是乱后的蜀中街头、寻常路人、俗眼白。杜甫借一位画师的小传，写出了盛唐转衰的全过程，并在\"圉人太仆皆惆怅\"这种细节里隐伏对玄宗耽艺忘国的微词。这首诗之所以被人称作\"七言古诗的冠冕\"，不全在它的画技描写精彩，更在它把一个时代的兴衰压进了一个画师的一生——这种气象学的笔法，才是它真正难学处。","assets":{"poem_id":"0b8b1899dd68","title":"丹青引赠曹将军霸","version_name":"唐诗气象版","appreciation_title":"唐诗气象：一位画师小传里藏着的盛唐转衰","author":"杜甫","dynasty":"唐代","poem_text":"将军魏武之子孙，于今为庶为清门。\n英雄割据虽已矣，文采风流今尚存。\n学书初学卫夫人，但恨无过王右军。\n丹青不知老将至，富贵于我如浮云。\n开元之中常引见，承恩数上南薰殿。\n凌烟功臣少颜色，将军下笔开生面。\n良相头上进贤冠，猛将腰间大羽箭。\n褒公鄂公毛发动，英姿飒爽来酣战。\n先帝天马玉花骢，画工如山貌不同。\n是日牵来赤墀下，迥立阊阖生长风。\n诏谓将军拂绢素，意匠惨澹经营中。\n斯须九重真龙出，一洗万古凡马空。\n玉花却在御榻上，榻上庭前屹相向。\n至尊含笑催赐金，圉人太仆皆惆怅。\n弟子韩干早入室，亦能画马穷殊相。\n干惟画肉不画骨，忍使骅骝气凋丧。\n将军画善盖有神，必逢佳士亦写真。\n即今漂泊干戈际，屡貌寻常行路人。\n途穷反遭俗眼白，世上未有如公贫。\n但看古来盛名下，终日坎壈缠其身。","source_url":"https://www.bilibili.com/video/BV1st4y1b7PX","skill":"appreciate-tangshi","generated_at":"2026-07-02T17:58:24+00:00","public_dir":"/appreciation/0b8b1899dd68","article_path":"/appreciation/0b8b1899dd68/version-4f9234a6a4.md","metadata_path":"/appreciation/0b8b1899dd68/version-4f9234a6a4.metadata.json","transcript_path":"/appreciation/0b8b1899dd68/version-4f9234a6a4.transcript.md","review_path":""},"source":{"type":"bilibili","url":"https://www.bilibili.com/video/BV1st4y1b7PX","transcript_file":"/Users/bupt_absinth/Work/projects/poetry/skill/appreciate_tangshi/bilibili/丹青引赠曹将军霸/BV1st4y1b7PX/merged_transcript.md"},"review":"","source_url":"https://www.bilibili.com/video/BV1st4y1b7PX","generated_at":"2026-07-02T17:58:24+00:00"},{"version_name":"文本考据版","title":"文本考据：卫夫人、凌烟阁与韩干画肉怎样把曹霸定位到画史坐标系","body":"## 一、核心判断\n\n读《丹青引赠曹将军霸》的人常被它的画马段吸引，却容易忽略全诗开头那几句用典。可若是细看，会发现这首诗的用典密度极高——卫夫人、王右军、凌烟阁二十四功臣、褒公鄂公、玉花骢、韩干画肉不画骨——这些典故不是装饰，而是杜甫借美术史坐标系把曹霸定位到\"上承阎立本、下压韩干\"的位置。考证这些典故的来源与背景，才能看出杜甫\"抑韩扬曹\"的判断在画史上的分量，也才能看出他写曹霸\"画骨\"之功的真正指向。\n\n我在这篇赏析里要讨论的，正是这套用典背后的画史定位——它不是空泛的赞美，是一次精准的美术史坐标测量。\n\n## 二、从关键诗句进入\n\n要从\"学书初学卫夫人，但恨无过王右军\"这两句进入。这两句看似只是交代曹霸学艺的起点，其实已经把曹霸放进了一个文化的师承谱系里。\n\n卫夫人名铄，字茂漪，晋汝阴太守李矩之妻，是书圣王羲之的书法老师。这一笔看似闲笔，其实要紧——曹霸学书初学卫夫人，等于与王羲之同出一门。这是杜甫给曹霸一个高贵的师承起点：你不是从无名处学起，你是从书圣之师学起。可下一句立刻翻案：\"但恨无过王右军\"——曹霸在书法上自恨未能超过王羲之，遂转向绘画。这一\"恨\"字极妙：它既写曹霸对自己的高标准（不甘居师门之下），又写曹霸转向绘画的内在动因（书法有王羲之在前，绘画尚有可为）。\n\n这八句开头实际上是把曹霸放进两条师承谱系里——书法上承卫夫人、王羲之，绘画上凌烟阁功臣重绘则上承阎立本。师承既高贵，转向又有自觉。这是杜甫给曹霸的第一层画史定位：起点高，转向自觉。\n\n## 三、诗意如何转深\n\n第二条画史坐标在\"凌烟功臣少颜色，将军下笔开生面\"这一段。这一段用典更密，定位更深。\n\n凌烟阁是唐太宗贞观十七年（643）所建，画二十四功臣像以表彰功勋。最初由阎立本绘制——阎立本是初唐大画家，传世《步辇图》《历代帝王图》皆归其名。开元中，凌烟阁画像颜色暗淡，玄宗命曹霸重画。这一笔用典的要紧处在于：曹霸重绘凌烟阁，等于接了阎立本的活儿。杜甫不直说曹霸与阎立本并驾齐驱，可这一笔用典本身就是定位——能接阎立本之笔者，画史地位已可坐实。\n\n接下来的\"良相头上进贤冠，猛将腰间大羽箭\"是细节。\"褒公鄂公毛发动，英姿飒爽来酣战\"——褒国公段志玄、鄂国公尉迟敬德，皆为凌烟阁二十四功臣之列。段志玄是唐初名将，《旧唐书》有传；尉迟敬德更是凌烟阁二十四功臣里最显赫的一位，后来的门神原型。曹霸笔下这两位功臣\"毛发动\"\"英姿飒爽来酣战\"——脸上毛发如动、英姿飒爽如欲酣战。这是杜甫在写曹霸画人物的功力：不是形似，是神似，是画中人物几乎要从画里走出来。\n\n这五句用典连用——凌烟阁、阎立本、褒公段志玄、鄂公尉迟敬德——把曹霸的人物画定位到了唐初功臣画像的最高序列里。能把这个序列的画像重画得\"毛发动\"\"来酣战\"，曹霸的人物画功底就已经与阎立本并肩。\n\n## 四、必要考据\n\n- 卫夫人名铄，字茂漪，晋汝阴太守李矩之妻。传为王羲之书法老师，有《笔阵图》一篇传世（真伪有争议）。唐张怀瓘《书断》列其隶书入妙品。\n- 王右军即王羲之，官至右军将军，故称\"王右军\"。杜甫此句\"但恨无过王右军\"化用《论语》\"画地为牢\"式的高标准自我设限——以书圣为不可逾越之高峰。\n- 凌烟阁二十四功臣为唐太宗贞观十七年（643）诏画，画师为阎立本。二十四人包括长孙无忌、魏征、房玄龄、杜如晦、段志玄、尉迟敬德、李靖等。事见《旧唐书·太宗本纪》《唐会要》。\n- 褒国公段志玄，唐初名将，《旧唐书》卷六十八有传。鄂国公尉迟敬德，本名尉迟恭，唐初名将，《旧唐书》卷六十八有传。两人皆列凌烟阁二十四功臣。\n- 阎立本（约601—673），初唐大画家，官至右相。传世作品多归于其名者有《步辇图》《历代帝王图》，真伪学界仍有讨论，但其作为初唐画坛盟主的地位历代无异议。\n- 玉花骢为玄宗内厩名马，骢指青白花色马。唐诗中多见玄宗内厩名马之名，如照夜白、玉花骢、百花骢等。\n- 韩干，唐代画家，京兆（今陕西西安）人，活动于开元、天宝间。初师曹霸，后被玄宗召为内教博士。传世作品有《照夜白图》（现藏纽约大都会艺术博物馆）、《牧马图》（现藏台北故宫博物院）等。\n- \"进贤冠\"为黑布冠，唐代百官朝会所戴，见《旧唐书·舆服志》。\n- \"大羽箭\"为长箭，传唐太宗李世民善射，喜用大羽箭。见《新唐书·兵志》相关记载。\n\n## 五、比较与定位\n\n可以拿张彦远《历代名画记》对韩干的评价做对照。张彦远是晚唐画史大家，他在《历代名画记》卷九里推韩干画马\"遂为古今独步\"——这与杜甫\"干惟画肉不画骨，忍使骅骝气凋丧\"的判断明显不同。今观韩干《照夜白图》，画中马拴于柱上、肥壮嘶鸣，筋骨确被皮肉所掩，但神骏之气并未全失——可见杜甫此评历来有\"抑韩扬曹\"之议。\n\n可杜甫的\"偏颇\"恰恰是有意为之。他写韩干\"画肉不画骨\"，是要反衬曹霸\"画骨\"之功。肉可见可摸，骨在皮内不可见，画肉易、画骨难——这是杜甫借韩干立曹霸的画论判断。这一判断不必合于画史定论，但合于这首诗的逻辑需要：杜甫要在曹霸身上写出一个画师的至高境界，必须借一个对照。韩干是曹霸弟子、画史地位足以并列，正是最合适的对照对象。\n\n更能照亮本诗的对照，是杜甫《画马赞》及《房兵曹胡马》对马之神的写法。《房兵曹胡马》写马之神落在\"竹批双耳峻，风入四蹄轻\"——具体的耳与蹄；《丹青引》写曹霸画马之神落在\"斯须九重真龙出，一洗万古凡马空\"——画成之后的评价。一真一画，但杜甫对\"马之神\"的把握始终在\"骨\"与\"神\"二字上，与他在本诗对韩干\"画肉不画骨\"的批评互为表里。\n\n## 六、总评\n\n《丹青引》全诗的用典不是堆砌，是一次精密的画史定位。卫夫人、王右军定位曹霸的师承起点——上承书圣之师；凌烟阁、阎立本定位曹霸的人物画——上承初唐画坛盟主；褒公鄂公定位曹霸的画功深度——画中人物毛发动、来酣战；玉花骢定位曹霸的画马高度——一洗万古凡马空；韩干画肉不画骨定位曹霸的画骨之功——虽弟子已擅名，仍不及师。这五层定位层层递进，最后把曹霸安到了画史坐标系上一个既具体又崇高的位置。读这首诗若只看见画马段的精彩，便辜负了杜甫的画史野心——他要做的不是夸一位画师，是把一位画师写进画史。","assets":{"poem_id":"0b8b1899dd68","title":"丹青引赠曹将军霸","version_name":"文本考据版","appreciation_title":"文本考据：卫夫人、凌烟阁与韩干画肉怎样把曹霸定位到画史坐标系","author":"杜甫","dynasty":"唐代","poem_text":"将军魏武之子孙，于今为庶为清门。\n英雄割据虽已矣，文采风流今尚存。\n学书初学卫夫人，但恨无过王右军。\n丹青不知老将至，富贵于我如浮云。\n开元之中常引见，承恩数上南薰殿。\n凌烟功臣少颜色，将军下笔开生面。\n良相头上进贤冠，猛将腰间大羽箭。\n褒公鄂公毛发动，英姿飒爽来酣战。\n先帝天马玉花骢，画工如山貌不同。\n是日牵来赤墀下，迥立阊阖生长风。\n诏谓将军拂绢素，意匠惨澹经营中。\n斯须九重真龙出，一洗万古凡马空。\n玉花却在御榻上，榻上庭前屹相向。\n至尊含笑催赐金，圉人太仆皆惆怅。\n弟子韩干早入室，亦能画马穷殊相。\n干惟画肉不画骨，忍使骅骝气凋丧。\n将军画善盖有神，必逢佳士亦写真。\n即今漂泊干戈际，屡貌寻常行路人。\n途穷反遭俗眼白，世上未有如公贫。\n但看古来盛名下，终日坎壈缠其身。","source_url":"https://www.bilibili.com/video/BV1st4y1b7PX","skill":"appreciate-tangshi","generated_at":"2026-07-02T17:59:21+00:00","public_dir":"/appreciation/0b8b1899dd68","article_path":"/appreciation/0b8b1899dd68/version-ad11a0cf58.md","metadata_path":"/appreciation/0b8b1899dd68/version-ad11a0cf58.metadata.json","transcript_path":"/appreciation/0b8b1899dd68/version-ad11a0cf58.transcript.md","review_path":""},"source":{"type":"bilibili","url":"https://www.bilibili.com/video/BV1st4y1b7PX","transcript_file":"/Users/bupt_absinth/Work/projects/poetry/skill/appreciate_tangshi/bilibili/丹青引赠曹将军霸/BV1st4y1b7PX/merged_transcript.md"},"review":"","source_url":"https://www.bilibili.com/video/BV1st4y1b7PX","generated_at":"2026-07-02T17:59:21+00:00"}]}